top of page

Building on a Gulf Island: the Islands Trust, the CRD and the Permit Path

Oct 20
12 min read
Gulf Island Construction Site

A house on Salt Spring, Pender, Galiano, Mayne, Saturna or Gabriola answers to two governments before it answers to you. The Islands Trust decides what can be built on the lot and where. The regional district decides how it is built and issues the permit. Neither will hurry, both are reasonable when the application is complete, and the hand-off between them is where most island timelines are lost. This is the path as it stands in late 2026, with the numbers that matter and the points where we ask first and design second.


What the Islands Trust is for


The Islands Trust Act gives the Trust one object: "to preserve and protect the Trust Area and its unique amenities and environment for the benefit of the residents of the Trust Area and of British Columbia generally." Every official community plan and land use bylaw on the islands must be consistent with the Trust's Policy Statement, and regional growth strategies do not apply inside the Trust Area. The Policy Statement in force is Trust Council Bylaw 17, which the Trust itself says has not been meaningfully updated since 1994.

That is changing, slowly. A new draft Policy Statement, Bylaw 183, received first reading at a special Trust Council meeting on July 29, 2025. Public engagement ran until February 2, 2026. The Trust's own guidance is that adoption is not expected before the end of 2027 at the earliest, and that the new statement will govern bylaws written after adoption rather than reopening the ones in force. The draft's direction is clear enough to plan around now: one policy states that land-use density should not increase in watersheds without an adequate or sustainable freshwater supply. Water, not architecture, is the thing the Trust is most likely to say no to.

For a single house on an existing lot, the practical reading is this. A dwelling is a permitted use in the residential zones on each island; the Trust does not decide whether you may build. It decides where on the lot the house sits, how close it comes to the shoreline, streams, lakes and slopes it protects, whether anything about the project adds density, and what you must prove about water before a permit can issue.


Who decides what


The Trust works through a local trust committee for each island, and the committee's decisions are the ones that reach a house: development permits where the lot touches a protected area, development variance permits when a setback or height cannot be met, temporary use permits (valid three years, renewable once for three more), and rezoning. A Board of Variance can relieve a siting rule on hardship grounds but cannot change use or density. Subdivision is not the Trust's decision at all; it goes to the provincial Approving Officer, who asks the Trust to confirm the proposal is consistent with the bylaws.

Building permits are issued by the regional district, not the Trust: the Capital Regional District for Salt Spring and the Southern Gulf Islands, the Regional District of Nanaimo for Gabriola. The two are joined by a form. The CRD's application checklist, revised in October 2026, requires a Building Permit Review Response Form from Islands Trust planning staff confirming that the site plan and drawings comply with the land use bylaw and the development permit areas, and it states plainly that the plans submitted to the Trust and to the CRD "must be identical." The Trust review therefore comes before the permit, and a drawing changed after it means a second trip. Gabriola runs the same logic through an Islands Trust Review Declaration on the RDN's form, with the RDN advising applicants to discuss the proposal with Trust staff before applying.

Trust application fees are set island by island under each committee's fee bylaw, so the current figure is always the island's own. The scale comes from the Trust's model fee bylaw, reported in 2022: a development variance permit at $1,900, a temporary use permit at $2,150, a Board of Variance application at $2,200, and rezoning at $4,600 to $7,800, with committees able to vary those by 20 per cent either way. Those fees recover less than a tenth of what the work costs the Trust; a February 2025 report put one quarter's application processing at about 3,300 staff hours against under $10,000 in fee revenue, and a tenfold increase was discussed without being adopted. The point for an owner is not the fee. It is that the Trust's planning capacity is thin, and a complete application that needs no second look is the fastest kind.

One efficiency worth knowing: on Salt Spring, the committee delegated marine shoreline development permit decisions to staff in 2022, so a clean shoreline permit does not have to wait for a committee meeting. Variances and temporary use permits still go to the committee after notice to neighbours.


Development permit areas: where the house can sit


Each island's official community plan draws development permit areas, and whether your house falls inside one is the single biggest variable in the permit path. Salt Spring's plan is the most detailed. Its shoreline area covers the sea out to 300 metres and the land within 10 metres of the natural boundary where the marine environment is sensitive; removing a tree over 20 centimetres in trunk diameter or exposing more than 9 square metres of bare soil inside that strip is not exempt, and any shoreline stabilization needs a professional engineer with geotechnical experience. Its lakes and streams area runs 10 metres from streams, 61 metres from most lakes and 300 metres from Maxwell Lake, and a septic field within 61 metres of a lake is not exempt. There are further areas for community well capture zones, unstable slopes and soil erosion, and riparian areas added in 2014. Gabriola's land use bylaw sets a 15 metre building setback from the natural boundary of the sea. Galiano replaced its old elevated catchment area with a groundwater recharge protection area in a plan amendment the Minister approved on July 7, 2025.

What a development permit costs is measured in reports more than fees. A May 2025 memo on a Salt Spring shoreline application lists what staff required: a geohazard report, a marine shoreline assessment, an environmental report by a registered professional biologist and a letter of advice from Fisheries and Oceans Canada. The permit was not issued. That is the lesson, and it is why we site the house before we design it. A house held outside the protected strips needs none of those reports. A house 8 metres from the sea needs all of them, and may still be refused.


The building permit


The CRD rewrote its building bylaw for applications received on or after March 1, 2026. The application fee is a flat $300, non-refundable. The permit fee is 1.4 per cent of construction value, and it now bundles the demolition, plumbing and fireplace fees that used to be separate. A permit lasts four years instead of two, and the owner has a year rather than six months to start work. The CRD's review target is four weeks with complete documents; an application that cannot be issued within six months is cancelled and the fee forfeited, and a permit can be renewed once, for up to a year, if the request is in within 30 days of expiry. Fines for building without a permit now run from $1,000 to $50,000, each day a separate offence.

The checklist for a new house on an island is long and most of it must exist before the application does: proof of potable water, meaning a well log with coliform and mineral tests, a water district approval letter where there is a district, and for a rainwater supply a mechanical engineering design; the Island Health record of sewerage system filing; the Islands Trust review form; confirmation that the property is not in an archaeologically sensitive area, from the Archaeology Branch or a consulting archaeologist; a title search no more than 30 days old; the BC Housing new home registration; sealed engineering schedules; and an energy advisor's confirmation, because the CRD requires Energy Step Code Step 3 and Zero Carbon Step Code EL-3 for every new building in its electoral areas. A land surveyor's foundation certificate is required before the first framing inspection.

Inspections on the islands run to the inspector's sailing schedule. The CRD's posted days are the first and third Tuesday of each month on Galiano, the second Tuesday on Saturna, Tuesdays on Mayne, Monday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday on Pender, and the third Tuesday of each month for James, Moresby, Piers and Sidney islands. Salt Spring is split at Rainbow Road: north on Monday, Wednesday and Friday, south on Tuesday and Thursday. Notice is 24 hours, 48 for the final, booked by 3 pm, and the CRD warns that the Southern Gulf Islands may need more. A framing inspection missed on Saturna is a month of schedule, and we build the schedule from the inspection calendar outward rather than the other way.

Gabriola's permit comes from the Regional District of Nanaimo under a fee bylaw in force since May 15, 2025: an application fee of $1,000 for a project over $100,000, credited to the permit fee, which is $250 plus 1 per cent of construction value above $20,000. The RDN has required Step 3 for houses since May 1, 2023, with a mid-construction blower door test, and its archaeological sites declaration allows no land alteration before the permit issues.


Water: proving it before the permit


The Trust's water rules bite at two moments: subdivision and building permit. For a single house, the permit rule is the one that matters, and on the unserviced islands it is a cistern. Mayne requires a minimum of 13,640 litres of cistern capacity for each additional dwelling on the lots its bylaw lists. Galiano's new groundwater bylaw, given its adoption report in September 2025, withholds the building permit for any new dwelling outside a water service area unless a freshwater cistern of at least 18,000 litres is installed, up from 16,000; confirm its final adoption with the Trust before you size the tank. Saturna's bylaw sets 21,820 litres, with a 2026 amendment that would reduce it to 18,000 awaiting adoption. The CRD then asks for the well log and water tests, or the engineered rainwater design, before the permit.

On Salt Spring the question is different. The North Salt Spring Waterworks District stopped new connections in 2014. It partly reopened on the Maxwell Lake side on March 31, 2025, with an annual cap equivalent to about 300 multi-unit dwellings, first come first served; the St. Mary Lake side remains closed. In 2025 the district approved 61 connections, 36 of them for BC Housing's Drake Road project, which used roughly a fifth of the cap. Its new Maxwell Lake treatment plant broke ground in March 2026 at $16.6 million and is due online in 2027. If your Salt Spring lot is in the district, the connection letter is the first document to chase; if it is outside, the well and the cistern are.

Domestic wells need no provincial licence, but any well drilled or altered since February 29, 2016 must be reported to the provincial well registry within 90 days, and the Water, Power and Septic article covers saltwater intrusion, which is the real risk in a coastal well.


Septic: the field decides the site plan


Island Health, not the CRD, governs the septic system. Under the provincial Sewerage System Regulation only an authorized person, a registered onsite wastewater practitioner or a professional engineer, may design and install it, and that person files the system with Island Health before construction and a letter of certification within 30 days of completion. The filing fee was $200 when Island Health last published it, and a filing is valid for two years. Type 1 is a septic tank and field; Type 2 and Type 3 add treatment to tighter effluent standards, and only an engineer may design a Type 3.

Setbacks from the provincial standard practice manual drive the site plan: a dispersal field 30 metres from a well, 30 metres from a lake or stream, 15 metres from the sea, 3 metres from a property line and 7.5 metres from a point where effluent could break out downslope. On a small waterfront lot those circles can leave one place for the field and therefore one place for the house, which is why the practitioner's site assessment belongs before the architect's first sketch. A 2026 Board of Variance application on a Salt Spring islet asks to reduce a field setback from 30 metres to 10, which is what happens when the order is reversed.


Archaeology and First Nations


Under the Heritage Conservation Act, archaeological sites are protected on private land whether or not they have been recorded, and the shell middens that mark thousands of years of Coast Salish settlement are concentrated exactly where houses want to go: the beaches, bays and bluffs. An archaeological assessment on Mayne in April 2025 noted that most of the sites registered on the island contain shell midden and contacted fourteen First Nations. The CRD now asks every new-house applicant to confirm the property is not in a sensitive area, and the Province warns that some heritage permit applications take more than 200 days. Permits and provincial information are free; the archaeologist's time is the owner's cost, and on a shoreline lot it is money well spent before the excavator arrives.

First Nations consultation also shapes the bylaws themselves. Salt Spring's accessory dwelling bylaw passed three readings in January 2024 and was then deferred in March after a letter from the Tsawout First Nation, whose Fulford reserve is the only one on the island. Expect the same care in any island decision that touches shoreline or density, and build the Trust's chance-find protocol into the site plan from the start.


How long it takes


The CRD's four-week review is the fast part. The Trust publishes no service standard, and its timelines depend on whether the file needs a committee decision, professional reports, referrals or a bylaw change. One Salt Spring shoreline file was submitted complete in late December 2023, received a file number in July 2024, a staff decision in May 2025 and a committee decision on July 10, 2025. Galiano's groundwater bylaws went from first reading in March 2023 to an adoption report in September 2025. Those are outliers in one direction, but they set the range. A house sited outside every development permit area, on a lot with a proven well and a filed septic design, can be permitted in a season. A house that needs a variance and a shoreline permit should plan on a year before the first inspection.

The provincial small-scale multi-unit housing rules that reshaped Greater Victoria's zoning in 2024 do not apply on Trust lands, so the density and height changes you may have read about on the Peninsula do not reach the islands. The CRD's Rural Housing Program, a three-year pilot from 2025, does: it rebates half the construction cost of an accessory dwelling, to $40,000, on Salt Spring and the Southern Gulf Islands for owners who rent it below market for five years.


How we run an island permit


We start with the Trust, not the drawings. Before any design money is spent we read the zoning and development permit maps against the survey, walk the lot for the shoreline, slope and tree constraints, and get the Trust's staff view of what will need a permit and what will not. The well test, the septic site assessment and, where the shoreline suggests it, the archaeologist's overview come next, because together they decide where the house can go. Then the design, with your architect or one of our design partners, sited to avoid variances wherever the lot allows, and a permit package assembled against the CRD's checklist so the four-week clock starts once. The inspection calendar for your island is in the schedule before the contract is signed, and from there the project manager and site manager run it the way we run every job, with the daily record where you can see it.


Questions we're asked


Do I need the Islands Trust's permission to build a house? Not permission to build, but confirmation that the house complies. The CRD will not issue a permit without the Trust's review form, and if the house sits in a development permit area or needs a variance, that is a Trust decision first.

What does a CRD building permit cost in 2026? A $300 application fee and a permit fee of 1.4 per cent of construction value, under the bylaw in force since March 1, 2026. On Gabriola the RDN charges $250 plus 1 per cent of value above $20,000, with a $1,000 application fee credited to it.

How much water do I need to show? On the unserviced islands, a cistern of at least the island's minimum, which is 13,640 litres on Mayne for additional dwellings, 18,000 on Galiano under its new bylaw and 21,820 on Saturna under the current one, plus a well log and tests or an engineered rainwater design for the CRD. On Salt Spring, a letter from the waterworks district if you are inside it.

Will I need a development permit? If any part of the work touches a shoreline, stream, lake, steep slope or other mapped area, yes, and it will need professional reports. Siting the house outside those areas is the single best way to shorten the path.

How long will it take? The CRD targets four weeks with a complete application. The Trust side ranges from weeks for a straightforward file to well over a year where a variance, a shoreline permit or a bylaw question is involved. We give you a range for your lot once we have read it.

Does the Province's multi-unit housing law apply on the islands? No. Lands under the Islands Trust Act are exempt. The CRD's rural housing pilot, which rebates up to $40,000 toward an accessory dwelling rented below market, does apply on Salt Spring and the Southern Gulf Islands.


Start a conversation


Tell us which island and which lot. We'll tell you what the Trust will want to see, what the CRD will want to see, and the order to get it in.

It's time for a home

built around you. 

Uncompromising Craftsmanship Since 1998

bottom of page