top of page

Building a Home on ALR, Acreage or Estate Land on the Saanich Peninsula: House-Size Caps, Residential Footprints and Farm Class

Oct 22
10 min read
Saanich ALR Farm

The acreages that attract estate buyers to the Saanich Peninsula are, for the most part, farmland. Sixty-one per cent of Central Saanich sits in the Agricultural Land Reserve, thirty-seven per cent of North Saanich does, and Saanich counts 2,665 agricultural parcels. The Reserve is not a reason to look elsewhere; it is a set of rules that decide how big the house can be, where it can sit, what else can stand near it and how the land is taxed. Most of those rules can be designed around. A few cannot. This is what they are in late 2026, for the Province, for each Peninsula municipality and for the rural districts nearby, and how we design an estate home inside them.


The provincial rules: 500 square metres and a footprint


Since February 22, 2019 the Agricultural Land Commission Act has capped a principal residence in the Reserve at 500 square metres of total floor area, measured to the outside of the exterior walls, with an attached garage excluded up to 42 square metres and basements and crawl spaces excluded entirely. A house of that size needs no application to the Commission, and the Commission's own bulletin is explicit that no farming is required for it: one residence is permitted on a parcel whether or not the land is farmed. A larger house needs a non-adhering residential use application, at $900, decided by the Commission after the municipality forwards it. The Commission's policy for those applications, revised in May 2025, suggests a residential footprint of no more than 2,000 square metres for the principal residence and 1,000 for an additional one, set generally within 60 metres of the road frontage, and weighs how the house relates to the farm even though farm necessity is not the legal test for a larger principal residence. In 2024–25 the Commission decided 61 such applications and approved 43.

The second residence is where estate plans meet the Act. The regulation allows one additional residence of up to 90 square metres on a parcel of 40 hectares or less without a Commission decision, provided the municipal bylaw permits it, and it may house family or anyone else. Anything beyond that, a second full house or a third dwelling, must be necessary for a farm use, which the Commission judges against the scale of the farm and the contribution of the people who will live there. Accessory buildings follow a May 2026 guideline: workshops, detached garages and storage of no more than 90 square metres in total on a parcel of 40 hectares or less, single storey, with no sleeping areas, recreation rooms, gyms or spas, and a detached garage only where the house and its attached garage are within the cap. Pools, tennis courts, basketball courts, fountains and playgrounds are, in the Commission's words, generally not considered necessary, and the Commission allows them only where the circumstances are unusual and the effect on arable land is slight.

Fill is the rule that catches builders. A principal residence may be built with fill affecting up to 1,000 square metres, driveway included, without an application; anything larger, and any fill at all for an additional residence, an alteration or an accessory structure, needs a notice of intent, filed at least 60 days before the work for $150, with building plans attached. The Commission received 446 notices in 2024–25 and refused a quarter of them. Construction waste, asphalt, glass, treated wood and unchipped lumber are prohibited fill everywhere. Enforcement is real: 27 stop-work orders and nine penalty orders totalling $512,000 in the same year, with administrative penalties reported to run to $100,000.


Saanich: the farm residential footprint


Saanich wrote the Commission's suggestion into its bylaw. Since January 1, 2026 every A-zoned lot of 2,000 square metres or more has a farm residential footprint: a maximum of 1,000 square metres on lots to 4,999 square metres, 1,500 to 19,999 and 2,000 above, located within 40 metres of the front lot line on an undeveloped lot. The footprint must contain the house, the garages, any pool, sports court or gym, the residential well and septic field and the parking, and a replacement house must sit inside the original footprint; a larger footprint needs a variance from Council. Saanich's house cap is tighter than the Province's: the lesser of a floor space ratio of 0.45 or 400 square metres, which is about 4,300 square feet, at a height of 7.5 metres, with the house 7.5 metres from front and rear lines and 3 from the sides on a minimum lot of 2 hectares. Saanich's soil bylaw requires Commission approval or a confirmed permitted use before any soil is moved on Reserve land, at $500 plus a dollar a cubic metre with a security and fines to $50,000, and its 2024 development permit guidelines include a rural interface fire hazard area.


Central Saanich: the cluster rule


Central Saanich's zoning bylaw, No. 2270 of 2026, which the District posted in July, caps the principal residence in its Agriculture zone at 500 square metres of gross floor area, measured to exclude basements and the first 28 square metres of garage, at 8 metres in height, 7.5 metres from the front and rear lines, 1.5 from an interior side and 6 from a flanking street. A lot under a hectare may add one secondary unit, a suite, cottage or carriage house; a lot of a hectare or more may have both a suite and a detached unit of up to 90 square metres, but only where the principal residence is 500 square metres or less, and no building containing a dwelling may stand more than 50 metres from another, which is the District's way of keeping the houses clustered. Fences in agricultural zones may run to 2.5 metres, retaining walls to two tiers of 1.2 metres, and the minimum agricultural lot is 4 hectares. The District's agricultural properties page adds the practical rules: accessory buildings may have two plumbing fixtures and no kitchen or shower, a residence on agricultural land is subject to the environmental development permit even though farm practices are not, any new floor area near an existing septic system needs an authorized person's compliance letter, and initial building permit reviews run about four to six weeks. Central Saanich's community plan counts 152 farms and more than 2,679 acres of crop land, supports no further subdivision of agricultural land and no non-adhering residential use that does not serve agriculture.


North Saanich: bigger zones, a bylaw in transition


North Saanich's rural zones are the Peninsula's most generous on paper. Under the 2011 zoning bylaw a single-family house may reach 465 square metres on a lot under 4,000 square metres and 650 square metres on larger lots in the RA-1, RA-2 and RA-3 zones, with 588 and 558 in RA-4 and RA-5, at 11.5 metres in height with 7.6 metre setbacks, on minimum lots of 20 hectares in RA-1, 4 in RA-2, 2 in RA-3, 8,000 square metres in RA-4 and 4,000 in RA-5. On Reserve land the provincial 500 square metre cap governs regardless. A guest cottage of 92 square metres is permitted on lots of half a hectare or more in RA-2 to RA-5, but in the Reserve only where essential to the farm. The District's community plan, adopted July 14, 2025, sets no subdivision below 20 hectares on agricultural land and 4 in rural, a steep slopes development permit area for slopes over 30 per cent, and no sewer extension beyond the existing service area. The new zoning bylaw, No. 1606, was given first reading on April 27, 2026 and was not adopted before the October election; the readable draft tightens the Reserve cottage to 90 square metres for farm workers with Commission approval, measures Reserve floor area with the garage excluded to 42 square metres, and keeps buildings 15 metres from the sea. Staff expect a revised draft before the new council in November, with the Province pressing for more duplexes and carriage houses. Until it passes, the 2011 bylaw governs, and any North Saanich estate design should be checked against both.


The rural districts next door


Metchosin, which has no sewer, allows one accessory dwelling on lots under 0.8 hectares as a suite inside the house, a detached suite or carriage house on larger lots, and on Reserve lots of 0.8 hectares or more both a suite and a detached unit, with the detached unit at least 15 metres from every lot line. Highlands sets minimum lots of 0.4 hectares in its RR1 zone and 0.8 in RR2, allows an accessory dwelling under a covenant, and limits accessory buildings to 325 square metres in aggregate; its council gave readings in April 2026 to a bylaw capping a principal dwelling at 700 square metres in sixteen zones, counting garages, and held public hearings in May and June, with adoption to be confirmed. The direction across the region is the same: the house is capped, the footprint is defined, and the estate is designed to fit.


Farm class, and what it does and does not save


Farm classification is the tax question estate buyers ask first, and the answer is narrower than the brochures suggest. Land qualifies as farm class when it produces farm income above a threshold set by size: $10,000 a year on a parcel under 0.8 hectares, $2,500 on 0.8 to 4 hectares, and $2,500 plus 5 per cent of the land's farm value above 4 hectares, with sales in two reporting periods and an application by October 31. The land under a farmer's dwelling is farm class where the dwelling is occupied by someone actively involved in the day-to-day work of the farm, and unused Reserve land can qualify where part of the parcel is farmed. The house itself is always residential class, assessed at market value and fully taxable in a municipality; other farm buildings are largely exempt. Farm land is valued on a prescribed schedule rather than at market, which is why the farm rate per thousand dollars is higher than the residential rate in every Peninsula municipality and the bill is still lower.

For an owner who will not farm, the realistic route to farm class is a lease to a working farmer, with the income and the activity on the parcel rather than in the owner's hands, and the house paying residential tax regardless. Two other taxes behave as elsewhere. The property transfer tax's newly built home exemption applies only to parcels of half a hectare or less, so an acreage house does not get it, though a family farm transfer has its own exemption. The speculation and vacancy tax applies in all thirteen municipalities of the region, with an exemption during construction where the owner proceeds without undue delay.


Water, septic, fire and the driveway


Most Peninsula acreages draw municipal water from the regional system that serves Central Saanich, Sidney and North Saanich, and most are on septic; North Saanich's sewer serves five neighbourhoods and will not be extended. The building bylaws require an approved water source of sufficient capacity for drinking and fire protection where there is no municipal service, and Island Health's acceptance of the septic design before the permit. The Province's small-scale housing manual tells municipalities to allow only in-house suites, not detached units, on unsewered lots under a hectare, which is the origin of the one-additional-unit rule on most acreages. The regional water, power and septic article in this series covers the systems; the point here is that the well, the field and its reserve area all sit inside the residential footprint in Saanich, and the footprint fills faster than owners expect.

Fire and access complete the site plan. Langford's development permit guidelines show where the region is heading: fire-resistant siding and roofing within 30 metres of high-risk forest, fuel removed 10 to 20 metres from buildings and reduced to 30, and exterior sprinklers where water supply is short. Saanich allows one driveway access per parcel, Oak Bay caps driveway grade at 15 per cent, Highlands caps the first 10 metres at 15 per cent, Langford requires a fire access route 4.5 metres wide at no more than 15 per cent with a connection at both ends beyond 90 metres or sprinklers instead, and the CRD requires a fire-vehicle driveway within 30 metres of the house. A long private drive through the trees is an estate's best feature and its most regulated one.


Designing the estate inside the rules


The plan starts with the footprint: a rectangle within 40 metres of the road in Saanich, a cluster within 50 metres of the other dwellings in Central Saanich, 60 metres of the frontage in the Commission's guidance, holding the house, the garage, the pool if it is permitted, the well, the septic field with its reserve and the parking, drawn before the house is. The house is then designed down rather than out: 500 square metres measured to the outside of the walls is about 5,400 square feet above grade, basements and crawl spaces are free, and the garage exclusion is 42 square metres under the Province and 28 in Central Saanich. The accessory buildings are kept to 90 square metres in total, single storey, without the gym the owner wanted, which goes in the basement instead. The second residence is drawn at 90 square metres and sited where the municipality allows it, and anything larger is planned around the Commission's timeline: a target of 60 business days that it met for 29 per cent of applications in 2024–25 and 90 days for 53 per cent. Fill is counted before the excavator arrives, the notice of intent filed 60 days ahead where any accessory structure needs it, and the arable land left arable, because the Commission's inspectors read site plans too.


How we build on acreage


We read the parcel against the Reserve map, the municipal zone, the footprint rule and the title before any design money is spent, and we tell you plainly which of the things you want the rules allow, which need an application and which will not be approved. The footprint, the services and the access are fixed first; the house, with your architect or one of our design partners, is drawn inside them; the Commission's notice or application goes in early where it is needed; and the price is settled with the selections before the permit. Then the project manager and the site manager build it, with the daily record where you can see it.


Questions we're asked


Can we build a house on ALR land if we don't farm? Yes. One principal residence of up to 500 square metres is permitted on a parcel without a Commission application and without any farming requirement, where the municipal zoning allows a house.

How big can the house be? 500 square metres under the Act, measured to the outside of the walls with basements excluded and an attached garage excluded to 42 square metres. Saanich's A zone caps it at 400 square metres or a floor space ratio of 0.45, whichever is less. North Saanich's zones allow more on paper, but the Reserve cap governs on Reserve land.

Can we have a pool or a tennis court? The Commission's 2026 guideline says they are generally not considered necessary and allows them only in unusual cases. Saanich counts them inside the farm residential footprint. Plan on an application and an uncertain answer.

Can we build a second house for family? One additional residence of up to 90 square metres is allowed without a Commission decision where the municipality permits it; Central Saanich allows it on lots of a hectare or more, North Saanich's current bylaw only where essential to the farm. A larger second house must be necessary for a farm use.

Will the property get farm status? Only with qualifying farm income on the land, which for a non-farming owner usually means a lease to a working farmer. The house is taxed as residential either way.

How long does the Commission take? Its targets are 60 business days for most applications and 90 for the majority; in 2024–25 it met them 29 and 53 per cent of the time. A notice of intent for fill runs on a 60-day clock.


Start a conversation


Tell us the parcel. We'll tell you how big the house can be, where it can stand, what else the land will carry, and what to apply for before you draw.



It's time for a home

built around you. 

Uncompromising Craftsmanship Since 1998

bottom of page